North Oaks vs. Google
Saturday, May 31st, 2008You might have caught this article today in the Star Tribune. It’s about the private north suburb community of North Oaks requesting that Google Maps remove photos of their properties from its Street View function. By the way, it’s a really cool feature that allows you to see photos from various street addresses. If you haven’t played with it, I encourage you to give it a try. If you’re house hunting, it’s yet another way to burn innumerbal hours on-line searching for your next real estate quest.
The gist of the article is that North Oaks contends no one can enter to take photos of homes without trespassing on their private property - thus making any posted pictures ill-gotten goods. Google complied with their request and took down North Oak maps. But if you read the electronic comments left by readers on the Star Tribune website, it seems the general public are not with the good people of North Oaks. Comments range from calling residents paranoid to accusing them of class warfare.
This surprises me. I mean, it’s private property and the folks in North Oaks pay for all the roads and infrastructure themselves. It seems well within their rights.
When I wrote the Neighborhood Spotlight column for the Star Tribune a few years back, I had to stand on the street and take pictures of homes as examples of real estate in a given place. I hated doing it.
I used to tell my editor, Jim, that he’d have to bail me out or visit me in the hospital should I end up in an altercation over the practice. Luckily, I never did, but I know I ruffled some feathers and got some stare downs from residents. But I knew I had the law on my side with public road under my feet.
In the case of North Oaks, there is no public space from which to photograph from. And if North Oakians want to exercise their right to privacy, I see no reason why they shouldn’t. In a world with paparazzi stalking celebrities at every turn and nothing is too sacred to throw onto the World Wide Web, I find it refreshing for a group to decide to opt out of it all.
If you want to opt out as well, the Star Tribune kindly provided these instructions:
HOW TO TAKE YOUR HOME OFF STREET VIEW
• Go to maps.google.com.
• Enter any address and click on “street view.”
• Click on “street view help” in the image window.
• Click on “report inappropriate image.”
What’s your take?










